Category: Cocktail Bar, News

Home » Magazine » Mixology » Cocktail Bar » 50 Best Bars – Europe: Does it make sense to introduce a new ranking in the world of bars?
50 best bars in Europe
Home » Magazine » Mixology » Cocktail Bar » 50 Best Bars – Europe: Does it make sense to introduce a new ranking in the world of bars?

50 Best Bars – Europe: Does it make sense to introduce a new ranking in the world of bars?

Share
50 best bars in Europe

We should have talked about it at the bar. A stool each, the usual slow rotation of glasses, that suspended moment needed when trying to figure out if something new is truly new or just another variation on a theme. The crunch of ice, the smell of the polished wood of the bar, the soft light gliding over the bottles. But no. Me in Florence, my friend and colleague. Charles Carnival In Milan. He himself works every day within the bar system, with the gaze of both the observer and the inevitably observed.

So our conversation doesn't start with a toast, but with a vocaloneIt arrives on the phone while I'm walking through the streets of Florence, and it already has everything: enthusiasm, annoyance, lucidity, disenchantment. It's his way of reacting to the recent announcement of the arrival in Europe from the 50 Best Bars, yet another ranking that promises to capture the best of the continent and which, inevitably, reignites the debate on what it means to count in the world of mixology today.

50 best Europe

The vocalone It's one of those things you can't dismiss with a "I'll listen to it later." You have to stop, lean against the wall, put your hands in your pockets. Pause. Really listen. Because Carlo isn't talking. against a ranking, but environment to everything a ranking affects: visibility, expectations, money, positioning, narratives. In a word: the bar system.

When I call him back, we laugh together, and for a moment I can almost see him there, his impeccable hair, his unbuttoned coat, and his quick Milanese gaze, observing everything and everyone. "We should have had this chat at the counter," I say, trying to mimic the relaxed tone of a real conversation. He laughs, and I hear the rapid rhythm of someone who's already worked out a hundred scenarios: "Yes, but before we see each other again..." Like a Frecciarossa train, his voice travels from Milan to Florence and captivates me immediately.

50 best bars in Europe
Charles Carnival

Carlo, is this new 50 Best Bars Europe good news?

"It depends on who's looking at it and where they're looking at it," he begins, with that tone that oscillates between analysis and barroom reflection. "If you broaden the geographic coverage, it's undeniable that it's an opportunity for visibility. There are excellent bars that have never played this game before—because it's now clear what a game it is—and they can finally get on the radar."

I try to understand better: "But don't you think it risks creating further pressure on venues that are already doing well and have never sought international recognition? Perhaps bars with a consolidated identity, who don't want to 'play' for the rankings..."

50 best Europe
Rita

Carlo nods, leaning forward slightly as if to underline the importance of his words: "Exactly. The Europe of the bar is not a single block: it's a messy, layered mosaic, full of stories that don't always lend themselves to the international spotlight. Think of realities like the Rita or the MAG in Milan. Twenty years of work, continuity, and a very strong identity. They're not part of any global circuit, yet they are beacons. This ranking can also serve this purpose: to demonstrate that excellence isn't just that which travels to guest artists and festivals.

I feel the weight of his statements and I articulate them within me like the sound of ice in a glass: "There's also a generational and territorial issue: some bars have never needed to legitimize themselves outside their own context. They function, they work, they endure. That's no small thing, in fact," Carlo continues.

50 best Europe
MAG

Then I add: "And then, as always, rankings have their economic side. It's not just recognition: it brings visitors, investment, energy to devote... and not all venues can sustain that wave. For example, I'm thinking of certain venues in Naples or Turin: wonderful work, enormous creativity, but they've never sought an international stage. For them, this can be more of a risk than an opportunity."

So far, it almost seems like a toast to innovation. But it doesn't take much for the tone to change. I can feel it in the air between the words of the voice message. "And the cons?" I press him, lowering my voice slightly, as if someone approaches to confide a secret. "The first is obvious: it's another media and economic tool. A lot of money is in circulation. It's another channel in which money is invested and generated. And above all, it risks diverting the attention of bars that have always done very well from day-to-day business to chasing the rankings," says Carlo, and in his words I hear all the experience of someone who knows the system from the inside.

Arriving is one thing. Staying is another."It's one thing to get in, and another to stay there," he continues, cocking his head like someone looking into the distance. "Because when you enter a ranking like that, you change your audience. You're no longer just talking to local customers. You're talking to those who search for 'best bar in...' on Google. And that wave isn't easy to sustain, neither financially nor personally."

Finally, here's the most uncomfortable part, the one that forces you to look at the system critically. "And let's not forget," Carlo continues, "that as in any system, there are shady dynamics. Attendance, votes, favors... in short, a bit of corruption—let's call it that—is always there. It's not scandalous, but you have to be aware of its existence. Those who get in, those who stay, and those who are highlighted aren't always the result of excellent work alone: there are other factors at play."

The vocalone, listened to again after hours, sounds even clearer. It's not nostalgia, it's not rejection. It's a cry for attention. Because the bar, before being a ranking, is a daily chore. And describing it solely through rankings and awards risks betraying its complexity. "The problem," my interlocutor concludes, "is that we end up always talking about the brilliant stuff. But all the critical issues that no one talks about remain under the rug. So the idea gets around that everything is beautiful, everything smells good, when in reality the bar is a very tough job."

50 best bars in Europe
Giacomo Iacobellis and Carlo Carnevale

I close with a calmer voice, almost as if to reiterate a sense of shared responsibility: «So, if we want to read this 50 Best Europe like a photograph, we must remember that it is more of a reflecting mirror than an absolute truth. It must be taken with critical and informed eyes. And the reader must know that behind every name there is a complicated story." The last sentence is the one that remains. "After all, getting in the spotlight is easy. The hard part is not getting cooked. And continuing to do well what you did before, when no one was watching," Carlo concludes.

We're not at the bar.

But the conversation, in the end, is exactly that.

All that's missing is a Martini.

Share

Subscribe to our

newsletter

stay updated.

Privacy Policy