Six hours, dozens of tastings, and a far from simple question: how much can you reinvent a classic without ceasing to recognize it?
Judge a Espresso Martini It's a more complicated exercise than you might imagine. Especially when you have a card, a pen, and the task of explaining why one idea works and another doesn't. When I was asked to join the judging panel for the first Espresso Martini Challenge, I accepted with enthusiasm and with that kind of recklessness that often accompanies seemingly simple decisions. After all, I thought, it's about tasting Espresso Martini. How complicated could it possibly be?
The answer, after a day of judging them, is: very much.
The recipe is seemingly simple and, precisely because of this, ruthless. Few ingredients mean few places to hide: vodka, coffee, sugar, possibly coffee liqueur, and that foam that must appear spontaneous despite being the product of a little applied physics treatise. There's practically nothing that can be thrown in there to make up the numbers.

And it is precisely from this apparent simplicity that the first one started Espresso Martini Challenge, conceived and promoted by MT Magazine with the support of Finlandia Vodka And Vergnano CoffeeTwo different worlds, but perfectly suited to the challenge: on the one hand, a vodka with a clean and smooth profile, on the other, a coffee culture deeply rooted in Italian tradition.
Once you're on the other side of the counter, however, the brand quickly fades into the background and the raw materials remain. You need to understand how they're used, how the ingredients interact, and above all, whether the person in front of you can transform a recipe into something with its own identity.
This was, for me, the most interesting question of the Challenge: How much room is there left to tell something new without stopping speaking the language of the original?
The problem of the classics
A classic is a curious thing. Everyone wants to respect it, everyone wants to reinterpret it, and almost no one wants to leave it alone. The Espresso Martini also faces a particularly amusing contradiction: it's relatively young, yet it's already treated with the reverence we normally reserve for monuments.
The bartenders who made it to the finals approached this contradiction in different ways. Some sought precision, focusing primarily on extraction, temperature, dilution, and texture. Others sought a more personal signature, tweaking the aromatic profile, the sweetness, or the narrative construction.

And it's precisely here, as a judge, that I found the most interesting insights. A good Espresso Martini isn't necessarily the one that surprises you at the first sip. Sometimes it's the one that makes you want a second one without being able to immediately explain why. And this, in the world of mixology, is a less obvious quality than it seems.
Coffee is not a detail
One of the things this Challenge has highlighted is how easy it is to talk about coffee and how much more difficult it is to truly treat it as a blending ingredient. It's not simply "something bitter and aromatic to add to vodka." It's a living substance, extremely sensitive to temperature, extraction, grind, time, and the composition of the blend.
And above all, it changes rapidly.
This makes the Espresso Martini almost a learning exercise: the recipe written on the menu is only one part of the result. The other happens at the precise moment the bartender extracts the coffee, adds it to the shaker, and assembles the drink.

Here the role of Vergnano Coffee It became particularly interesting for us judges too: it wasn't simply a matter of recognizing the presence of coffee, but of understanding how much the raw material had been understood and valued within the recipe.
Observing the contestants at the bar was therefore more interesting than just the final tasting. It was clear who was truly in control of the process and who, instead, relied a bit too much on hope. And hope, unfortunately, is not yet a blending technique recognized by the IBA.
The bartender, even before the cocktail
The other aspect I observed particularly closely was the way the contestants described what was in their glass. As a judge, along with Carlo Carnevale, I focused primarily on communication, storytelling, and the ability to transform a recipe into something memorable.
This is an often overlooked aspect. A cocktail isn't just a sum of milliliters: how it's presented, explained, and delivered to the customer also matters.

But be careful: telling doesn't mean talking a lot. In fact, sometimes the opposite is true.
During the Challenge, I listened to carefully crafted stories, some very effective, others perhaps a little too self-indulgent. It's an understandable temptation: when you've worked on a recipe for weeks, you want to share everything. The problem is, customers don't always want to listen to the full version of your thesis before drinking.
Storytelling works when it adds meaning to the drink. When it becomes a blanket under which to hide an unconvincing proposition, it simply becomes storytelling. And the drink, sooner or later, comes with the bill.
The Mystery Box: The Moment When the Masks Fall
The part I found most interesting about the Rome final was probably the Mystery Box. Preparing your signature dish at home, perfecting it for weeks, and arriving at the counter knowing exactly what to do is one thing. Receiving unexpected ingredients and building something meaningful in minutes is another.
This is where the craft emerges.

Not necessarily the most spectacular preparation, but the ability to take a raw ingredient, quickly understand it, and decide what to do with it. It's a form of practical intelligence that counts for a lot in bartending and is difficult to fake.
In those minutes, I saw important differences emerge: adaptability, pressure management, quick decision-making, but also the willingness to abandon an idea when you realize it's not working. This last one, perhaps, is the most difficult.

Because having an idea is relatively easy. Knowing when to abandon it is much more professional.
Sofia D'Agnano and the others
The victory of Sofia D'Agnano She arrived in a context where the gaps between the finalists were far from abysmal. Her "Marilù" demonstrated precise construction and a good ability to combine technique, recognizability, and storytelling. But what struck me most was her overall management of the performance: from the signature to the Mystery Box, including her attitude at the bar.

Here too, work on the products made available by partners became part of the test: Finlandia Vodka and Caffè Vergnano were not simply ingredients to be used, but two elements with precise characteristics to be understood and integrated without forcing them.
And standing at the bar is something you can only practice to a certain extent. There are bartenders who, as soon as they start working, suddenly seem to take up all the space around them. Not because they make noise, but because they have presence.
The other finalists, Mattia Teli, Pierangelo Raneri, Daniele Cardi, Grace Capasso And Jacopo Castigli, They brought different approaches and made it clear that the level of Italian mixology is now high enough to make a competition of this type anything but a simple catwalk.
Pros and cons of a first edition
If I had to find one major merit of the Challenge, it's that it chose a very specific theme. Not a generic cocktail competition, but a single drink, a recognizable aromatic universe, a key ingredient, and an implicit question: How much more can we say about something we think we already know?
It's a fertile question.
The inevitable limitation of a first edition is that such a format still has to find its definitive balance between technique, spectacle, storytelling, and evaluation. This is the fate of every competition: the more you try to measure creativity, the more careful you have to be not to turn it into a competition of conformity.
The risk is rewarding not necessarily the most interesting proposal, but the one that best meets the judges' expectations. It's a subtle but crucial distinction.
A competition should be able to recognize technique without stifling instinct, precision without making everything standardized, creativity without turning it into an exercise in virtuosity.
The first Espresso Martini Challenge, in my opinion, had the merit of putting these issues on the table. And that alone, for a first edition, is no small feat.

Photo and video by @Mike Tamasco




















